posted ago by Mad_King_Kalak ago by Mad_King_Kalak +2 / -0

OSD 401: The more unjust the law, the fewer mistakes you can make Guidance for people who don’t want to be toadies.

In some countries, when a CEO advocates for laws that people in the government do not like, those politicians coordinate a hit with their partners in state-adjacent media. They may even enlist the help of competing CEOs who, for the health of their own companies, need the government to like them. If the CEO doesn’t go willingly, the government executives can use vague, sweeping rules about trade and national security (often passed via administrative fiat, not through the legislature) to threaten fines, criminal investigations, and prison time.

In Russia, this culminates with the CEO falling out of a window.

The US government is not so gauche. If the Secretary of State thinks the President’s China policy is too dovish, and he fabricates intelligence which he then leaks to the New York Times in a multi-month conspiracy to depose the cofounder and CEO of the most valuable company in the world — specifically because that CEO advocated for different laws on trade with China than the laws that the Secretary of State wants — well, that’s just the kind of thing that happens in a free country. And if that plan succeeds, creates a power vacuum, and then the government, the New York Times, and the target CEO’s key business partners immediately coordinate a campaign for KYC laws for AI, well, just be grateful you don’t live in China, citizen. Remember, they’re the ones who hate freedom.

Last week, Jensen Huang was reminded of something he already knew better than most people: the government will play dirty. Laws are a best-effort abstraction around the constraints on government, but ultimately, the only constraints on any system are descriptive, not normative. Actors in a system will pursue their incentives as far as they can. “I know I can pursue my incentives, but should I?” is not a question that comes up much. And the type of pure soul to ask it certainly doesn’t exist in the Cabinet.

This is something gun owners know well. The system that enforces gun laws has no problem with imprisoning people for missing paperwork or harmless possession crimes. “I know I can enforce an unjust gun law, but should I?” doesn’t come up much. Yes, some rural sheriffs make announcements in that spirit, but they’re not the ones passing the laws. The people passing the laws have no such compunctions.

The problem with Jensen’s case is that it requires you to hold two ideas in your head from somewhat opposing camps:

Jensen was the target of a political hit job representing the government’s view that in America, CEOs serve at the pleasure of the White House.

Jensen would have been harder to target if he wasn’t banging his employees and customers.

https://opensourcedefense.substack.com/p/osd-401-the-more-unjust-the-law-the/comments