Condensed version of the evils of Rome.
(www.youtube.com)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (22)
sorted by:
I'm leaning more towards the Orthodox ideas towards the Bishop of Rome, believe it or not. Papal supremacy, at least how the magisterium defines it today, doesn't go fully back to the time of Peter, more the time of Great Schism. Like most prods, you don't know what the Catholic church actually believes, but only what you think it believes.
For 500 years weak ass prod theology has been ripped to shreds by minds greater than my own. What makes you think a meaningless exchange here will change anything? Still, chose a topic. A SINGLE topic. Like most prods you're going want to walk about the place grabbing shit you don't like at random. I dare you to restrict yourself to one single theological topic of disagreement.
How about a classic, maybe "once saved always saved" or infant baptism?
So you have no clear faith rooted in scripture. You just "lean towards" one thing or another.
Is a Catholic heretical doctrine. So it sounds like you don't know what you're talking about regarding that subject.
Anyway the entire criticism here is about the evils of Rome, and you still can't defend a single thing discussed in the video. You're just avoiding the true arguments here so you can make vague counter arguments from ignorance of the topic.
Typical prod. You define yourself by opposing what you think other people believe, rather than what you believe yourself. The key to understanding prod rebellion is that they never go after the Orthodox, or Chaldeans, or Coptics which have theology very, very close to Catholics.
They go after Catholics due to their rebellion against authority. Satan won a great victory with Luther.
Let me ask you this. Is there any level of evil, whether in official doctrine or actions from the highest Catholic authorities, which would make you say they are not of God?
Where do you draw the line? Assuming you actually are a believer in anything and not just leaning one way or another.
Ha, of course, you want to wander all over the marketplace and criticize goods at random.
Choose a specific topic. You called me out for not debating you, I'm calling you out for not choosing a topic.
Can't answer a simple question on the topic at hand? I will try again.
Is there any level of evil, whether in official doctrine or actions from the highest Catholic authorities, which would make you say they are not of God?
The question dodger dodges the question with another question, and ironically accuses me of dodging. Rather, don't dodge a topic. I set the terms here.
By the way, that question, my brother in Christ (which you are) is a leading question. It's akin to asking me "when did I stop beating my wife?" The purpose, a clear as saran wrap, is to try to invalidate the whole by invalidating a part.
You're going to say X or Y is evil (based on what standards, why your own of course) then conclude the rest of Catholicism is evil.
Don't try to deny it. It's a classic prod technique. You guys are all think alike. So, try again. Maybe purgatory? Or the perpetual virginity of Mary?