This has to be the least thought-out thread I've read in a while. Is there a problem with what they are doing? Yes. Is it as lacking of nuance and plain-as-day as you think? No.

The problem is that the technically smart atheists tend to end up on the left with their "science" where they break things down to their smallest points and then tend to extrapolate while all the dumb God-loving (not to imply that loving God makes you dumb) people end up on the right making the kind of brainless analysis that devolves into the preceding two comments.