I was triggered (haha) by a story all over the mainstream media today:
RUSSIA: Alexey Navalny, Putin’s Chief Opponent, Speaks Out After Prison Transfer – HE’S HELD IN A SOVIET GULAG (TGP 12/26/2023)
The point of this post is not to out Navalny as an Intelligence asset, which we will do only briefly, but to take a look at how thin the deception can be and still fool the consciousness of billions of people. Present company excepted, of course.
The zero-th item to note is that these types of analyses are very unpopular in conspiracy circles. That is, there are very few theorists left, where you have to at least string together a couple of facts with some analysis. They have been completely diluted (and I'm not disparaging) by people (God bless them) who are driven more by, "Yeah, that guy does suck! Upvote!" That's great and all, but if you're looking for more, read on.
Before we look at the general phenomenon, we'll only examine one conclusive detail to his phony story. You'll only be reading about it here, so note how easily an obvious contradiction flies by the rest of the world.
In the story linked above, you'll find a tweet dated the 26th from Navalny's blue-check account. Who cares what it says, because it's mere existence is directly contradicted here by Kira Yarmysh, Navalny's spokesperson:
Alexei Navalny ‘doing well’ after transfer to remote Arctic prison (The Independent 12/26/2023)
There's no way of reaching inmates, nor by mail nor by Internet, so it is practically impossible to contact someone directly.
I hope no troll is going to give us, "Ackshually, you can't email them, they can only tweet out." Although we'd all like to see that, it would still be pretty shameful.
The point is, one sheer lie serves one audience, and another sheer lie serves a different one. The two people making up these lies do not care whatsoever about coordinating them. Nor, as I have pointed out, do they need to.
As I referenced in the title, Navalny is a "Simulant". I don't know of any existing term for this type of "person". It's what I've come up with for the range of such people who go from absolutely authentic with a few phony aspects to outright "virtual persons" constructed from scratch.
Navalny seems to be a living, breathing human being. After that it gets very murky, which is what I'm trying to highlight. And what I'm really trying to highlight is how very thin it all is yet still yields successful, long-running psyop.
For example, this whole dumb, bullshit narrative about "disappearing" and "no one knew where he was for three weeks" until be was found "exiled to Sibera"? Did you know he was (supposedly) sent to the exact same place not quite three years ago?
What we know about the prison hospital where Alexei Navalny has been sent (Reuters 4/19/2021)
You can see the narrative at the time was that he was "recovering from Novichok poisoning (from Putin!)", and not "disappeared to Siberia". Yes, it's all just narrative, but everyone laps it right up.
But I want to stress how thin it all is, and always was. So this guy is supposed to be "Putin's opposition", right? I used Qwant to search on "putin navalny" and got--get this--27 hits. The nexus between the two is virtually non-existent.
Does Putin even know he exists, fake or real? It turns out the answer is probably not. The closest I can come is this video:
Putin says palace in Navalny report 'doesn't belong to me' | AFP (YouTube 1/25/2021)
If you watch the video, Putin never mentions Navalny. In fact, he says he never watched the video, only a summary made by his aides. My guess is that Putin is aware of the deception and chooses never to acknowledge it.
Finally, recall that Navalny is supposedly a politician seeking to challenge the highest-profile leader in the world, correct? He's got to get out there and kiss hands and shake babies, right? Apparently, no, he never does that.
Search for images with "navalny meets". It's him alone, in court, with his "family", and sometimes with some people floating around in the background. He never goes out and poses for photos with people he meets. Try the same search with something like "lauren boebert meets" and she's right there with all kinds of people. Maybe just a slut, huh?
Recall that "media" means "middle", and that's the shim that's created between people and reality. It may be razor-thin, but it's there and makes all the difference in the world.
Do your searches in Russian. :) Western media covered only tiny part of Navalny adventures that was suitable for the Western narratives.
Navalny was a murky businessman of kind, participated in money laundering with government owned businesses, like in that Kirovles case. It was regular practice at the time, when product of some state owned company (woddland plots and sawmill in that case) bought for the very low price and then reselled with market price. From the external point of view, there was nothing criminal - buy low, sell high, unless you know how that really work here. This state company sell wood only to Navalny company, because state bureaucrat who was in charge of that state company received huge part of Navalny company profits. Plain and simple corruption and state money laundering. When such schemes began to be criminalized, Navalny jump off and moved to some other less risky businesses. Nobody come after him, just because much larger fish was hunted at the time. But, probably, this ability to run away at the correct time attracted attention of some liberal politicians.
There was few other business adventures, also murky, when Navalny company again did absolutely nothing just being a money proxy.
Eventually, Navalny ended with owning some tiny business of making some wicker-work like chairs or something IIRC. Of course he didn't participate in any work, just was co-owner getting some small profit. And at that stage he decided to move into politics with agenda of fighting against corruption.
Pretty strange for the man who personally make all his weath on corruption.
Initially Navalny played liberal politician, but at the time it was already pretty obvious that liberal ideology is heavily anticipated by Russia population after the years of liberal reforms. You could easily find numerous Navalny meetings with all top liberal politicians of Russia. He often participated in round tables and whatever liberal meetings.
As I understand, Navalny turn to nationalism (fake turn, of course) happened after a group of nationalists disrupted one of liberal meetings where Navalny presented. He got that he will not acheve anything playing liberal, and even single nationalist have much more public support than all liberals together.
He began to participate in Russian marches and other nationalist events. and I suppose that was the moment when he was taken into hand by Western agencies.
West often used nationalism for intervention, but in case of real Russian nationalism that didn't work, really. Either Russian nationalist leaders deny any contacts with Western agencies agents, either such contacts ended with punched faces of western negotiators. One MI6 agent even ended in ICU, with accident filmed and shared over social media at the time, with few nationalist ended in jail for severe harm to health of victim.
But Navalny, being filthy liberal was completely another story. And what's most important, unlike any other nationalist leaders he had murky corrupt past that gives his curators good lever over him.
So, Navalny got financing and press and started his political campaign on the terms of nationalism, antiimmigration and anticorruption - highly popular things among people. But there was one thing people remembered well - he was the one who filed the case against nationalists who once disrupted his liberal meeting and that ended in jail time for one of nationalists for the "spreading of ethnic hatred". Such things are not welcomed in Russia.
Under the guise of that attractive slogans Navalny and his team pushed purely liberal narratives. Navalny once had some peak of popularity, but as more liberal crap like LGBTXYZ+ support began to appear in his agenda, his popularity significantly dropped. But Navalny and team had that finance flow from their Western partners and they started different election companies aiming at some not very high positions like majors of small towns and regional councils.
Nobody really would have been bothered with that attempts, if not the ties of Navalny organisation with Western agencies. Dropped popularity of Navalny do not allow him to achieve anything, but that "Western hand" always make Russian authorities angry. Many different small candidates without chances for win participate in elections, from radical communists to open nationalists and nobody gives a fuck.
As soon as Navalny sensed attention of Russian three-letter services he immidiately began to play a victim. Familiar behaviour, isn't it? This reduced his popularity even more. People still was interested in some dirty underwear Navalny with help of his Beliingcat(MI6) friends dug out on some Russian bureaucrats and oligarchs, but his game was already finished.
The rest of story was more or less represented in Western media from the necessary for the Western narrative angle.
Interesting that in the end, Navalny western masters just throw him under the bus, and then with their stupid sanctions helped Putin to do nearly everything that was in the most popular Navalny points. Seized Russia oligarchs foreing property, rised Russian nationalism to state ideology, clearly show horrors of uncontrolled migration and along with that made any western influence over Russia's wanna-be-politicians highly improbable.
Does Putin heard about Navalny at all? Of course he did. At the level somewhere between that black basketball junky caught with the stuff on the border and some governor from middle of nowhere who tried to swallow too much.
Can you link us to a video where Putin mentions him by name?
I don't think such video exists. Just like no video exists where he names that black basketball junky. But that does not mean he didn't know about them.
Okay, thanks! I just wanted to make sure it was okay to be certain about stuff we just make up about the world and post here.