Do you (U/ghost_of_aswartz) still believe we went to the Moon?
(www.youtube.com)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (28)
sorted by:
If you move the fishbowl in a circular motion with a period of 24 hours, then the fish won't even be able to perceive the motion, even if the radius of the circle is thousands of miles. If you whip it around in a tight loop, then the water will become turbulent and the fish will get knocked around.
If there's a current, the fish will move with it. Depending on its swimming ability, it will be able to swim against some amount of current. What analogy are you trying to make? Is it a controversial idea that a fish can swim?
I'm not trying to make a point that the air carries objects along with it, even though that's generally true. I'm saying that the air, objects that happen to be in the air, and the ground the air is above are all rotating at effectively the same speed and direction, and gravity keeps everything curving back toward the ground, and so there's no constant energy required to keep from falling off the earth.
The air is rotating with the Earth too, and there's no reason for it not to on average because it's the lowest energy state.
Speed is always relative to another reference frame. If you're riding in an airplane and eating a peanut, you could say the peanut is going 400mph and it would be true relative to the ground, but it's not going 400mph relative to your mouth. Relative to the surrounding air, maybe it's going 380mph if there's a 20mph tailwind. Relative to the sun, the peanut is probably going a bajillion mph. The only energy/power required is for the plane to overcome the aerodynamic drag from moving relative to the air, and the constant 9.8m/s^2 acceleration upward to counteract gravity.
Said another way, there's no energy required to maintain a constant rate of rotation for matter that's held together by natural forces in a closed system, only momentum. The Earth overall is largely a closed system, as it is moving though a vacuum. Over cosmic time scales, though, the Earth does lose momentum because it's not a perfectly closed system. Days are becoming slightly longer from year to year. Some of that is due to tidal forces with the moon, for example.
Two considerations to add to this:
most planes ascend to 20-30,000 feet in order to minimize the drag of the atmosphere
“jet streams” and similar phenomena can go counter to the earths rotation. The atmosphere is a highly “chaotic” system and things are moving in all directions at once, it’s just the average or prevailing movement that follows the rotation, theoretically:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Tracks