I agree with you fully. The mods definitely need to approach moderation with a leniency. Dissenting opinion is what makes conspiracy theories so enjoyable.
With that being said, there is a fine line between dissent and shilling or trolling. I have confidence that our mods will operate in good faith. With the years of moderation experience combined, these mods are up to the task.
It's almost as if they don't trust it. Not surprising in the least.