Well, to be honest here... I am not that knowledgeable about the specifics on different denominations, and I am not even a native English-speaker, so it took me some time to check what some of the words meant. But, as I can understand it, after I checked the meanings of the words, I do agree with your position, as much as I am aware on Protestantism and Catholicism.

I also checked his replies and he is definitely not as coherent and knowledgeable as you portray him. Not that you're making any mistakes, but I admire how you present his stance on the debate, while not even focusing on the petty insults he is constantly using in his comments. This is a remarkable composure from you, I must say.

I would be studying the differences in the different denominations in more detail, to fully grasp what you are saying. But regarding your statement that "maybe" you should be posting this in c/catholic... Friend... You have so much knowledge and understanding that you present in comments. You should definitely be posting a lot, and not even in this specific forum. I see your recent posts are mainly great quotes from the Bible, but your second-to-last post is showing great understanding, and the details are what is very useful for people, who study Christianity. In my opinion, you should be focusing more on posting these type of breakdowns, and explanations. I am not saying you should stop with the Biblical quotes, but you have such knowledge and understanding that is vital for the Christians, who want to believe, but don't fully grasp many of the concepts, like me. Perhaps I am just basing this incorrectly on your last posts, but you should definitely write more free text, or just keep writing free text posts.