How does the climate work on a flat earth? Why does it get colder the further north or south or up you go?
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (92)
sorted by:
You misunderstand.
Models are not for explanation.
Consider the geocentric model. We have it, and it still works very well today. Does that prove that the universe is geocentric?
Models are not for explanation - they are for (limited) use!
Having a model or not having a model is meaningless. Analogously, having an explanation or lacking one is equally meaningless. Furthermore, contriving explanation is trivial; Almost all mythology is explanation... What matters is if the explanations are correct!
If i had a model of a flat world (trivial, but time consuming, to create), surely that wouldn’t prove the world flat - right? For the exact same reasons the geocentric model doesn’t (and can’t, fundamentally) prove that the earth is the center of the universe.
Do you think that I am asking for a physical model like a diorama?
I am asking for a model in a sense that you provide measurements, a map, documentation of observations etc.
None of that seems to exist for a flat earth. Just vague claims and 5-hour long videos with more vague claims.
Lol. There is a lot of equivocation fallacy (often unintentional) surrounding the use of the word “model”. Most people have no idea what a scientific model is, how it is made, or why. For instance, you are under the (common/popularized) misapprehension that they are used, or can be used, to prove things about reality (either inside of science or outside of it).
In the scientific sense/use of the word “model”, no. There are many maps, conceptions, physical “dioramas” etc. available, however - but that is NOT the same thing, as you correctly point out.
What you are missing is that having or not having a model is meaningless. The earth remains the shape it is regardless of what our contrived models depict. Did you understand the point i was making about the geocentric model?
There is more than that (what you describe above, which i generally consider the flat earth psyop) but the heavily advertised (i.e. funded) flat earth psyop obfuscates it. That is one of its major purposes, ostensibly.
Earnest researchers, what i call flat earth researchers, do exist - and like most researchers - often do not make any videos. In any case, i loathe the 5 hour infotainment junk too.
Then present it.
You won't because you know that it doesn't exist.
Present what? I can’t help you find something if i don’t even know what you’re looking for. And i won’t help you find something if you don’t earnestly try to research/search for it first and fail. If i feed you fish, i make you a slave.
Understanding why you so desperately need this to be the case that you make silly proclamations like this will help you to identify your biases and be a better researcher. Assuming you are a human being, and earnest, i am happy to help when you are ready.