The real conversation here is that Silverman is 51 and Rogan is 39, although you could make the argument the ages seem reversed.
My understanding is that observant jews can't really ask others to do stuff for them on shabbat, although if someone offers they can accept.
I don't see the point of observing such restrictions if you're just going to bend the rules. It's like the eruv thing jewish people do in Manhattan.
https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/91594/theres-wire-above-manhattan-youve-probably-never-noticed
Many things they do are bizarre. They don't count anyone not born to a jewish mother as a jew. They are compelled to tell you their plans even if they deny them later.
You need immediate family. I think even if your mother's mother's mother was a jew, it doesn't count because that's too far removed. If there's any break in that, then you definitely don't count because you need the mothers to count.
The real conversation here is that Silverman is 51 and Rogan is 39, although you could make the argument the ages seem reversed. My understanding is that observant jews can't really ask others to do stuff for them on shabbat, although if someone offers they can accept.
I don't see the point of observing such restrictions if you're just going to bend the rules. It's like the eruv thing jewish people do in Manhattan. https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/91594/theres-wire-above-manhattan-youve-probably-never-noticed
Many things they do are bizarre. They don't count anyone not born to a jewish mother as a jew. They are compelled to tell you their plans even if they deny them later.
To what extent must one be Jewish? My mom is like 1/8 Jewish LOL. Does that win me my "right of return" or whatever BS?
You need immediate family. I think even if your mother's mother's mother was a jew, it doesn't count because that's too far removed. If there's any break in that, then you definitely don't count because you need the mothers to count.
How can there be a "break"? If my mother's grandmother was half Jewish, all female descendants will be part Jewish.
I'm far more Jewish than Elizabeth Warren is Native American, that's for sure.